Zeno of Elea
Achilles, the swift-footed hero, challenges a tortoise and gives it a small head start. When he reaches the point where the tortoise began, the animal has moved a little further. When Achilles reaches that next point, the tortoise has advanced again. And so on for ever: the hero will never catch it. The argument seems absurd, yet identifying its flaw occupied thinkers for centuries. Its author was Zeno of Elea.
Parmenides' pupil
Zeno was born in Elea around 490 BC and was Parmenides' pupil, bound to him by a very close relationship. Aristotle considered him the inventor of dialectic, the art of testing an opponent's arguments until their contradictions become apparent.
The paradoxes of motion
Four of his best-known arguments challenge the possibility of motion. Besides Achilles and the tortoise, the Dichotomy argues that to cover a distance one must first cover half of it, and before that half of that half, so that one can never begin. The Arrow states that at every instant a flying arrow occupies a space equal to itself and is therefore at rest. The Stadium concerns three rows of equal bodies: one stationary, one moving to the right and one to the left at the same speed. A moving row takes a certain time to pass a body in the stationary row, but half that time to pass a body in the row moving in the opposite direction. The same time therefore appears equal to half itself, which is absurd.
According to an interpretation going back to Plato, these paradoxes defended Parmenides by showing that ordinary ideas about motion and plurality also lead to absurd conclusions. Modern scholars debate Zeno's actual intentions, but agree on the immense influence of his arguments, which have challenged philosophers, mathematicians and physicists to this day.
The philosopher who defied a tyrant
Ancient sources also describe Zeno's courage. He allegedly took part in a conspiracy against a tyrant, whose name varies between writers; captured and tortured, rather than betray his companions he is said to have bitten off his tongue and spat it at his tormentor. The story survives in several versions and is closer to legend than reporting, but conveys the image of a courageous philosopher loyal to his city, as antiquity chose to remember him.