ELEA / VELIA
Elea / Velia

Melissus of Samos

Not every ancient philosopher spent his life among books and discussions. Melissus of Samos, the last major representative of the Eleatic school, was also a commander who led a fleet to victory.

A philosopher in command

Melissus came from Samos, an island in the Aegean Sea. In 441โ€“440 BC, during the war between Samos and Athens, he commanded his city's ships and defeated the Athenian fleet, as Plutarch records in his Life of Pericles. This is the only certain date in his biography. It is not known whether he was actually Parmenides' pupil, but his thought adopts and develops Parmenides' central ideas, which is why he is considered part of the school.

Being without boundaries

Melissus wrote a prose work, On Nature or On Being, of which a few fragments transcribed by Simplicius survive. Like Parmenides, he maintained that Being is one and eternal and that change perceived by the senses is illusory. On one decisive point, however, he differed: for Melissus, Being is infinite. If it had a boundary, it would border on something else, namely nothing, which cannot exist.

Being also has no beginning or end in time. Whereas for Parmenides Being simply is, for Melissus it was, is and will always be.

A thinker to rediscover

Aristotle judged his reasoning less rigorous than Parmenides', and for centuries Melissus was regarded as a lesser figure. Yet his clear prose helped spread Eleatic ideas throughout the Greek world. Between reflection on infinity and command of ships, he remains one of ancient philosophy's most unusual figures.

Further reading